Orange Frosting is a holiday exclusive frosting available during Thanksgiving in Papa's Cakeria and Papa's Cakeria HD. The frosting is unlocked on Rank 17 with Cara in Cakeria and Rank 52 with Sarah in Cakeria HD.
Orange Frosting is a standard frosting available in Papa's Cupcakeria (All Star). The frosting is unlocked on Rank 49 with Aliyah.
Orange Frosting is a standard frosting available in Papa's Cupcakeria Deluxe. The frosting is unlocked with Laura at Rank 50.