Nutty Butter Cup is a standard topping available in Papa's Cupcakeria (All Star). The topping is unlocked on Rank 9 with Trinity.
Nutty Butter Cup is a standard mixable available in Papa's Freezeria DELUXE. The mixable is unlocked from the start of the game.
Nutty Butter Cup is a standard mixable available in Papa's Freezeria Deluxe Refined. The mixable is unlocked from the start of the game.
Nutty Butter Cup is a sweet that children/customers can order in Trick or Treat!. The lolly is unlocked at Rank 3 with Haruki.
Nutty Butter Cup is a crust exclusive snack in The Snackbowl 2: Neapolitown exclusive for the Peanut Butter Swirl Crust. It gives 6 points and its speed is 100.
Nutty Butter Cup is a standard topping available in Papa's Cupcakeria Deluxe. The topping is unlocked with Laci at Rank 4.
Nutty Butter Cup is a standard placeable topping available in Mama's Frogurteria. It is unlocked on Rank 4.