Black Frosting is a holiday exclusive frosting available during Halloween in Papa's Cookieria. The frosting is unlocked on Day 2 of Halloween.
Black Frosting is a holiday exclusive frosting available during Halloween in Papa's Cakeria. The frosting is unlocked on Rank 12 with Mackenzie.
Black Frosting is a holiday exclusive frosting available during Halloween in Papa's Cakeria HD. The frosting is unlocked on Rank 43 with Aliah.
Black Frosting is a standard frosting available in Papa's Cupcakeria (All Star). The frosting is unlocked on Rank 45 with Nelli.
Black Frosting is a standard frosting available in Papa's Cupcakeria Deluxe. The frosting is unlocked with Meagan at Rank 40.